Casper vs. Tuft And Needle Mattresses

With the advent of mattress-in-a-box brands, shopping for a mattress has never been so seamless and stress-free. Direct-to-consumer mattress brands leverage technology to create a range of mattresses suitable for each person’s body needs, sleeping habits and circumstances. 

If you’re looking for a quality and comfortable mattress, you may have come across Casper and Tuft and Needle. While they both might have the benefits you need, which one is right for you?

What Is Casper? 

Established in 2014, Casper produces mattresses, pillows, bed frames and bedding products like sheets and pillowcases, as well as sleep-supporting devices that help you nod off and stay asleep.

All of its mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified and produced with eco-friendly materials. They are also regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission, which ensures the mattresses meet safety standards, specifically that they have low volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions that don’t affect indoor air quality.

The best part: Casper’s line of mattresses include a range of features for a good and uninterrupted night’s rest, including a durable base, memory foam, cooling technology, resilient springs and zoned support.

Casper’s mattresses are ideal for people who:

  • Experience body pains that may cause discomfort during sleep
  • Sleep hot or experience hot flashes
  • Sleep on their stomach, back or side
  • Share a bed with someone else
  • Switch sleeping positions at night

You may consider buying one of Casper’s models if you’re looking for a mattress that:

  • Cradles and contours your body
  • Provides pressure relief and ergonomic support
  • Is responsive to body movements on the bed
  • Supports motion isolation
  • Reduces heat and promotes coolness, breathability and airflow
  • Is soft and fluffy, yet firm enough to keep the body from feeling trapped in it

What Types of Mattresses Does Casper Offer?

Casper produces four foam and hybrid mattresses that accommodate buyers’ budgets, sleeping habits and preferences: the Original, Original Hybrid, Wave Hybrid and Wave Hybrid Snow. 

What Sizes Does Casper Offer?

All Casper mattresses come in six sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California King. The height and weight of each model varies, but their width and length remain the same:

  • Twin: ​​38″ W x 75″ L
  • Twin XL: 38″ W x 80″ L
  • Full: 53″ W x 75″ L
  • Queen: 60″ W x 80″ L
  • King: 76″ W x 80″ L
  • California King: 72″ W x 84″ L

How Much Does Casper Cost? 

Casper mattresses come at varying prices depending on the model and their features. The price also varies according to the size of the mattress. Here are the current prices for queen-size models:

  • Original: $1,495
  • Original Hybrid: $1,795
  • Wave Hybrid: $3,995
  • Wave Hybrid Snow: $4,495

What Warranty Options Does Casper Offer?

Casper offers a 10-year limited warranty for its mattresses, available to the first purchasers, which covers mattresses bought directly from them or authorized retailers in the U.S. and Canada.

The warranty covers defects due to the company’s materials and workmanship, but not damage done to it. The company also covers shipping costs for returning, repairing or replacing a defective mattress. 

You can also upgrade your mattress by paying the difference between the defective and new one.

Does Casper Offer Free Shipping?

Casper offers free shipping through UPS to the 48 contiguous U.S. states and some parts of Canada. However, customers in Alaska, Hawaii and northern Canada will pay shipping costs for purchases. 

Does Casper Offer a Trial Period? 

Casper offers a 100-night trial on mattresses you buy from them. If after using the mattress for 30 nights—known as the adjustment period—and deciding it’s not right for you, you can return it. They’ll also cover the return shipping cost.

What Is Tuft and Needle? 

Founded in 2012, Tuft and Needle is a trusted brand in the mattress market. In 2018, it merged with Serta Simmons Bedding, another industry-leading mattress brand, to push forward its mission to produce “exceptional, honestly-priced” sleep products, according to its mission statement.

Since its inception, it has remained a go-to mattress company for quality and affordable mattresses. The brand is rated 4.4 out of 5 stars from 15,375 reviews on Amazon.

Tuft and Needle also produces bed frames, sleep accessories and other bedding products like duvets, bedsheets, pillows and blankets.

Its Mint and Original Mattresses are UL GREENGUARD GOLD-certified, meaning they meet environmentally-friendly standards and don’t cause indoor air pollution. What’s more, its mattresses have also been awarded Intertek’s Clean Air Certification. This certification tests and endorses products that don’t compromise indoor air quality. They are also CertiPUR-U.S.-certified.

Tuft and Needle mattresses are well-suited for:

  • Lightweight sleepers
  • People who experience heat or hot flushes at night
  • Back sleepers, stomach sleepers, side sleepers and edge-of-bed sleepers 
  • Couples who sleep on the same bed
  • People who are restless sleepers
  • People who experience back pain

Their mattresses are also a great option if you prefer a mattress that:

  • Is eco-friendly
  • Is quality and cost-effective
  • Accommodates all sleeping positions
  • Holds firm and doesn’t allow the body to sink into the bed
  • Provides pressure point relief and body support
  • Moderately cushions the body 
  • Minimizes motion transfer 
  • Produces minimal noise
  • Is breathable, supports coolness and air circulation

What Types of Mattresses Does Tuft and Needle Offer?

Tuft and Needle offers three mattress models: the Mint, T&N Original and Hybrid mattress. 

These models come with a 7-inch support layer for the spine and back, 3-inch adaptive foam for ergonomic support and pressure relief and cooling gel and graphite to aid comfortable, relaxing sleep.

What Sizes Does Tuft and Needle Offer?

Tuft and Needle mattresses come in twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California King. 

Its Original mattress is 10 inches tall, and its Mint and Hybrid mattresses are 12 inches tall. The length and width dimensions for all sizes are:

  • Twin: 39″ W x 75″ L
  • Twin XL : 39″ W x 80″ L
  • Full: 54″ W x 75″ L
  • Queen: 60″ W x 80″ L
  • King: 76″ W x 80″ L
  • California King: 72″ W x 84″ L

How Much Does Tuft and Needle Cost?

  • The T&N Original mattress: $895 
  • The Mint: $1,195
  • The Hybrid twin: $1,695

They also offer customers the financing option of four interest-free installment payments.

What Warranty Options Does Tuft and Needle Offer?

Tuft and Needle offers a 10-year limited warranty for mattresses you purchase from its store or authorized distributors.

The warranty covers defects in the mattress or “any material breakdown of the foam that causes it to split, crack, or deteriorate in any other way,” according to the website.

Does Tuft and Needle Offer Free Shipping?

Tuft and Needle offers free shipping on select products within the contiguous U.S. 

Does Tuft and Needle Offer a Trial Period? 

Tuft and Needle offers a 100-night trial. If you purchase a mattress and realize it isn’t ideal  during the first 100 days, you can contact its customer experience team for help.

Casper vs. Tuft and Needle: Which Is Better for You?  

Casper offers a diverse line of mattresses that vary according to price, features and functions. Its mattresses may benefit anyone, but be particularly beneficial to people who experience body pains and hot flashes, love a cradle feeling without sinking into the bed and want a responsive yet firm mattress

Casper Mattress Pros and Cons

  • Free shipping for mattresses within the U.S. and some parts of Canada
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • 100-night trial period
  • Snow technology feature supports a cool sleep
  • The mattresses are pricey compared to other brands

On the other hand, Tuft and Needle may benefit people looking for an eco-friendly and affordable mattress that meets industry standards and supports cool and refreshing sleep. 

Plus, its mattresses are also suitable for people who experience body pains. They provide pressure-point relief and body support. Restless sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers, side sleepers and edge-of-bed sleepers may also enjoy sleeping on Tuft and Needle mattresses.

Tuft and Needle Mattress Pros and Cons

  • Cost-effective
  • Meet industry standards for safety and eco-friendliness 
  • You can pay in four installments 
  • Free shipping for most U.S. states 
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • 100-night trial period
  • 3-inch adaptive foam is suitable for people who don’t like the feel of memory foam
  • Accommodate most bedframes.
  • There have been complaints on Amazon that its mattresses are too firm and its edge support doesn’t work great, and edge-sleepers might feel like they’ll slip off the bed