When it comes to picking a mattress, you want to get it right, especially since the average human spends about a third of their lifetime sleeping or trying to sleep. Among many brands in the mattress space, Sealy and Beautyrest are two long-established choices you will likely come across, leaving you with one question: which one do you pick?
Luckily, we have done the research for you to create this detailed review, comparing Sealy and Beautyrest’s mattresses, which may help you understand the difference between these two brands and which one ultimately suits you more.
| Sealy | Beautyrest | |
|---|---|---|
| Type of mattresses offered | Memory foam, hybrid and innerspring | Hybrid |
| Available sizes | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king |
| Price Range (queen size) | $399 – $2,499 | $449 – $4,299 |
| Warranty | 10-year limited warranty | 10-year limited warranty |
| Sleep Trial | 100 nights | 100 nights |
About Sealy
Since 1881, Sealy claims to have “been helping American families sleep better by designing high-quality, trusted mattresses.” Originally designed in the U.S. before spreading globally, they’re likely one of the brands you think of when it comes to mattresses.
All Sealy mattress foams are CertiPUR-US certified, except the Naturals Hybrid, ensuring safety. The Naturals Hybrid is Greenguard Gold certified, meaning it is produced with eco-friendly materials. All Sealy products are also regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission, which means that their mattresses meet all safety guidelines, including having low volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions.
Sealy Mattress Options and Prices
The Sealy brand produces four mattress lines: Cocoon, Essentials, Posturepedic, Posturepedic Plus and Naturals. The popular Cocoon Chill mattresses feature an upgraded knit cover from the Classic version that helps dispel heat.
Sealy’s other lines, like the Essentials, come with two coil mattress options–the Euro top and the pillow top–which can offer cushioning and support. Its Posturepedic and Posturepedic Plus lines both feature targeted support that focuses on the heaviest parts of your body.
| Model | Sizes | Firmness | Mattress type | Price (Queen Size) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cocoon Chill | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Medium | Memory foam | $799.00 |
| Cocoon Chill Hybrid | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Medium | Hybrid | $1,099.00 |
| Sealy Essentials | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Medium, soft | Innerspring | $599.00 – $699.00 |
| Posturepedic Spring I | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft, medium and firm | Innerspring | $799.00 – $999.00 |
| Posturepedic Spring II | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft, medium, firm and ultra firm | Innerspring | $999.00 – $1,199.00 |
| Posturepedic Memory Foam | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft and firm | Memory foam | Not available online |
| Posturepedic Hybrid | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft and firm | Hybrid | $1,599.00 – $2,699.00 |
| Posturepedic Plus Spring I | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft and medium | Innerspring | Not available online |
| Posturepedic Plus Spring II | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Soft, medium and ultra firm | Innerspring | $1,399.00 – $1,499.00 |
| Posturepedic Plus Spring III | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king and split California king | Ultra soft, soft and firm | Innerspring | Not available online |
| Naturals | Twin XL, full, queen, king, California king and split California king | Soft, medium and firm | Hybrid | $2,999.00 |
Sealy Warranties and Discounts
The Sealy website mentions various discounts throughout the year, especially surrounding holidays.
The company also grants customers a 10-year limited warranty to all its mattresses. However, this only applies to defective products–sold by an authorized seller–due to faulty materials or construction.
What Users Say About Sealy
According to the reviews from ConsumerAffairs and the Sealy site, concerns with the mattress are mainly due to its stiffness, with some noting back pain as well.
A reviewer on the Sealy site said, “The mattress is too hard. Unfortunately, it’s hard to determine that without sleeping on it for several nights. Now that we have had it for over a year, it has not gotten any better. My back and sides hurt when waking up.”
As for the mattress itself, thousands of customers are satisfied and agree that the Sealy brand is a great buy.
“Our longest lasting mattress was a queen-sized Sealy Posturepedic which lasted almost 20 years,” said a customer from the ConsumerAffairs site. “The next two were Beautyrest – a queen plush top that was not comfortable too firm, and a king cushion – top that began to show where we slept within one year. So we went back to a Sealy, got a hybrid-softest because I had a hip injury. We are side and back sleepers. Have had it for two and a half years. So far so good. I often think of how good the mattress feels when I’m lying on it.”
About Beautyrest
Founded in 1870, Simmons, parent company to Beautyrest, introduced the Beautyrest line in 1925. Their Beautyrest Black collection later emerged in 2006. Beautyrest’s mattress fleet includes three different collections with a combined seven mattress models in total.
Just like its counterpart, Sealy, all foams in Beautyrest mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they meet indoor air quality standards and do not include harmful materials.
In addition to its Black, Harmony and Nate Berkus mattress collections, Beautyrest also sells bed frames and other bedding products.
Beautyrest Mattress Options and Prices
The Beautyrest line of mattresses includes all hybrid models, featuring various combinations of coils and foam. This includes the Beautyrest Black and Black Hybrid from the Black collection, the Harmony Lux Carbon, Harmony Lux Diamond, Harmony Lux Hybrid and Harmony from the Harmony collection and the Beautyrest by Natyre Berkus from the Nate Berkus collection.
The Beautyrest Black collection, uses its BLACKICE plant-based cooling technology to dissipate heat, which could be a plus for those who sleep hot.
Thanks to the introduction of the RightTemp Wave Foam, the Harmony collection should sleep cool and comfortable all night. For those who want a touch of luxury to their comfort, the Nate Berkus combines Nate’s signature designs with the Micro Diamond memory foam designed to absorb heat from your body and keep you cool while asleep.
| Model | Sizes | Firmness | Price (Queen Size) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Black Hybrid | Twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Firm | $2,399.00 |
| Black | twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Firm | $2,299.00 |
| Harmony Lux Carbon | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Extra firm, medium and plush | $1,399.00 |
| Harmony Lux Diamond | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Medium and plush | $1,899.00 |
| Harmony Lux Hybrid | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Firm | $1,599.00 |
| Harmony | Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king | Extra firm and plush | $1,099.00 |
| Beautyrest by Nate Berkus Mattress | Twin XL, queen, king and California king | Extra firm, medium and plush | $1,899.00 |
Beautyrest Warranties and Discounts
Like Sealy, Beautyrest also holds holiday sales, including its current Labor Day sale for example, which offers up to $1,000 off mattresses and adjustable base sets.
Simmons offers a 10-year limited warranty on its mattresses which covers the defects during production. It does not cover normal wear and tear that may occur while owning your mattress.
What Users Say About Beautyrest
According to the reviews from ConsumerAffairs, concerns with the mattress are mainly due to its softness or plushness as some say they would prefer something harder. Other than that, the majority like the brand for its high quality and comfort.
One customer review on ConsumerAffairs wrote, “Beautyrest mattress is one of the most comfortable and reasonably priced. Had back problems and this helps me sleep comfortably. Have owned one for three years and still supports like new. Would recommend for all sleep problems with different price ranges. You can’t afford not to have a Beautyrest.”
Sealy vs. Beautyrest: Which One Is Right for You?
Choosing the right mattress can be a big decision, especially considering the amount of time you spend in bed. Both the Sealy and Beautyrest brands have their respective pros and cons, so let’s close things out by comparing the features that stand out most.
Sealy Mattresses are ideal for:
- Budget shoppers
- Back support
- Those looking for a mattress collection that’s designed with orthopedic expertise, such as Posturepedic
Beautyrest Mattresses are ideal for:
- Those looking to purchase a hybrid mattress
- Mattress shoppers interested in a wide selection of accessories
- Shoppers who want complimentary White Glove Delivery
Both brands offer a 100-night risk-free trial. This means you can try out either of the two brands before sticking to the one that suits you more. Depending on the brand you choose, you can visit their site to make a purchase.