Sealy vs Serta

Have you been looking for a quality and trustworthy mattress brand? If you have, it’s likely you’ve come across these two manufacturers in the industry: Sealy and Serta.

If you’re stuck between the two brands or simply looking for some direction in your mattress search, here is some information to help you make a decision.

Sealy vs Serta

Type of mattresses offeredMemory foam, hybrid and innerspringMemory foam and hybrid
Available sizes per modelTwin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California kingTwin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king
Price range$399.00 – $2,499.00$314.10 – $3,599.00
Warranty10-year limited warranty10-year limited warranty
Sleep trial100 nights120 nights

About Sealy

Founded in 1881, Sealy currently offers five different mattress collections, as well as adjustable bases, pillows and bedsheets. Sealy mattresses are also made in the U.S. and have been for the last 140 years.

You can buy the Cocoon Chill from the Sealy and Cocoon by Sealy websites and the remaining models at retail stores. Authorized retailers nearest you can be found on its website. When shopping from the website, shipping is free and you can expect your mattress to arrive in five to seven days.

You also get a 100-night sleep trial period with your purchase. If you don’t like your mattress choice, you can return it for free during the trial and get your money back. 

Sealy Mattress Options and Prices

Sealy mattresses, which are available in memory foam, innerspring and hybrid models, are made from CertiPUR-US certified foams, speaking to the foam’s quality, eco-friendliness and durability. 

Here are the available Sealy mattress models and other details worth noting.

ModelTypeFirmnessPrice Range
Cocoon Chill Memory FoamMemory foamMedium$499.00 – $999.00
Cocoon Chill HybridHybridMedium$739.00 – 1,299.00
Sealy Essentials InnerspringMedium, soft$519.00 – $1,308.00
Posturepedic Spring IInnerspring Firm, medium, softPrices unavailable
Posturepedic Spring IIInnerspringUltra firm, medium, soft$899.00 – $2,288.00
Posturepedic FoamMemory foamSoft, firmPrices unavailable
Posturepedic HybridHybridSoft, firmPrices unavailable
Posturepedic Plus Spring IInnerspringMedium, soft$1,099.00
Posturepedic Plus Spring IIInnerspringUltra firm, medium, soft$1,299.00 – $2,898.00
Posturepedic Plus Spring IIIInnerspringFirm, soft, ultra softPrices unavailable
Sealy Naturals Hybrid HybridFirm, medium, soft$3,399.00 – $6,798.00

Sealy Warranties and Discounts

Sealy offers a 10-year warranty to first-time buyers of its mattress which covers replacements or repairs of mattresses that are deemed defective due to manufacturer error.

Currently, only Cocoon Chill is available at a discounted price, with 35% off plus free pillows and sheets. 

What Users Say About Sealy

Sealy has been serving consumers for over 140 years and has produced more than 100 million mattresses. 

Tempur Sealy International is Better Business Bureau (BBB) accredited and has an A+ rating on the site. This score is BBB’s view of how the company might interact with its customers. It’s rated 1 out of 5 stars on the website based on 124 customer reviews. 

The company has addressed over 610 complaints in the last three years and 224 complaints in the last 12 months. 

Sealy’s Cocoon Chill mattress has 3.7 out of 5 stars on Amazon. Many previous buyers were happy with the purchase, with 45% of reviews rated 5 stars 

One said: “I am currently recommending this mattress to everyone I know. I’m a plush mattress sleeper as is my boyfriend and we both swear by this mattress. Many memory foam mattresses can’t replicate the plushness of traditional mattresses, but this one somehow does just that and has all the benefits of a foam mattress. It has all the right sink and bounce we need to get a good night’s rest. We now have trouble sleeping anywhere else.”

A few others complained that the mattress wasn’t as soft as they expected, while some others said it was too soft. 

About Serta

Serta is another direct-to-consumer mattress brand that serves consumers in more than 150 countries. This mattress brand was founded in 1931 and is owned by Serta Simmons Bedding, one of the largest bedding manufacturers in North America. 

This company sells mattresses, bed frames, pillows, bedding sets, sheets and other mattress accessories. 

The mattresses are U.S.-designed and can be purchased from Serta’s website or at an authorized Serta retail store nearest you, which you can find through its website. These stores include Lowes, Mattress Firm, Sam’s Club and more. The company offers free shipping and returns, as well as a 120-night in-home trial for their mattresses. 

Serta Mattress Options and Prices

Serta produces memory foam and hybrid mattresses. These mattresses are toxin-free and certified by the STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX. The mattresses are also CertiPUR-US certified to be environmentally safe.

Here are the available Serta mattress models:

ModelTypeFirmnessPrice Range
Serta EZ Tote MattressMemory foamMedium-firm$349.00 – $599.00
Serta Serene Sky MattressFoamPlush$499.00 – $849.00
Perfect Sleeper Mattress-in-a-BoxMemory foam, hybridMedium-firm$549.00 – $999.00
Perfect Sleeper MattressMemory foamMedium$1,099.00 – $1,599.00
iComfort MattressMemory foamPlush$1,299.00 – $1,599.00
iComfort Hybrid MattressHybridMedium$1,199.00 – $2,099.00
Shinola x Serta 313 MattressMemory foamPlush$889.00 – $1,499.00
Serta Arctic MattressMemory foamPlush, Medium$2,099.00 – $4,099.00

Serta Warranties and Discounts

Serta offers a 10-year limited warranty that covers manufacturer’s defects and doesn’t include normal wear and tear or damage to the mattress from using it outside its usual purpose.

Currently, Serta isn’t offering any discounts on its mattresses. 

What Users Say About Serta

Serta has been in business for over 90 years selling mattresses and other sleep products to consumers in more than 150 countries.

Serta isn’t BBB accredited and has an F rating on the site. Many of the complaints on the website were about issues with the mattress quality, experiencing poor customer care service, and difficulty getting the company to fulfill the mattress’s warranty cover.

One buyer wrote: “I bought a queen size Serta Bed on the recommendations of a Serta representative on what type of bed to buy since [I am] 79 and having shoulder removal surgery shortly. I bought the mattress through [the] internet and paid Serta through [the] internet. When it was finally delivered, it was like a slab of cement. I called *****, who said Serta would be giving me back my money. Not a word from Serta. The order number was **********. I need my money back so I can buy a mattress before the operation. Nobody is taking responsibility and I’m left with a useless mattress Serta recommended. I paid $864.92.”

Serta memory foam mattress has 4.4 out of 5 stars from 315 ratings on Amazon. Many customers said it met and exceeded expectations, and for the right price. The negative reviews focused on the cooling technology with some users stating it doesn’t work to prevent night sweats.

Sealy vs. Serta: Which One Is Right for You?

Sealy and Serta are both long-lived mattress brands that could provide what you need in terms of variety, quality, durability, features and eco-friendliness. 

Sealy mattresses are ideal for someone interested in:

  • Shopping from Tempur Sealy International, the parent company of Sealy and other brands such as Tempur-Pedic and Stearns and Foster, with a wider range of mattresses to choose from
  • A mattress collection, such as Posturepedic, designed with orthopedic expertise
  • An environmentally responsible mattress like the Naturals Hybrid

Serta mattresses are ideal for someone interested in:

  • A lengthier sleep trial period of 120 nights
  • A more affordable mattress
  • Purchasing a mattress for use in the hospitality industry, such as a hotel

Both Sealy and Serta offer 10-year warranties, and with decades of mattress industry experience under both brands’ belts, you might find that a mattress from one of these brands will suit your needs quite nicely.