Best Mattresses at Wayfair

Wayfair is an e-commerce company based in Boston, Massachusetts that has a wide variety of mattresses for sale. The variety is so wide that it can often feel daunting when you’re trying to choose. To help you make the best choice for your lifestyle, we’ve done the work and sorted through the site to provide you the best of the best of what Wayfair has to offer when it comes to mattresses.

Winners

Casper Element Mattress

Price: $695.00 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Firm

4.5

Serta Perfect Sleeper Mattress

Price: $969.99 | Thickness: 12.5” | Firmness: Extra firm

4.3

Signature Design By Ashley Chime Ultra Plush Hybrid Mattress

Price: $379.99 | Thickness: 12” | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Casper Sleep 11” Medium Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $1,295.00 | Thickness: 11’’ | Firmness: Medium

4.3

Wayfair Sleep™ 8” Firm Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $179.99 | Thickness: 8’’ | Firmness: Firm

4.3

Wayfair Sleep™ Arviso 10” Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $375.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Medium firm

4.3

Wayfair Sleep™ King 10.5” Medium Hybrid Mattress

Price: $394.99 | Thickness: 10.5’’ | Firmness: Medium

4.3

Wayfair Sleep™ 10” Plush Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $329.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Wayfair Sleep™ 14” Plush Hybrid Mattress

Price: $469.99 | Thickness: 14’’ | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Novilla 10″ Medium Hybrid Mattress

Price: $489.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Medium firm

4

Who Should Buy a Wayfair Mattress?

Wayfair mattresses may be ideal for those looking to buy a budget mattress that doesn’t feel like a budget mattress. They’re also a great pick for individuals who prefer to shop online, and who like the idea of their mattress being delivered right to their door—often in its own compact box.

What to Consider When Buying a Wayfair Mattress

Quality and Cost

We spend about one-third of our lives asleep or trying to sleep, which makes a quality mattress pretty important. Wayfair has several mattresses manufactured and tested for quality. 

Another important factor is budget. The prices listed in this guide range from $263.99 to a max of $1,295, which should fit a wide variety of living situations. Additionally, Wayfair has ‘Open Box’ options; their name for a clearance section of items that were returned by customers.

Warranty, Return and Shipping Options

Wayfair says that they ship large items through “trusted carriers that specialize in handling large items.” Every mattress purchased through Wayfair comes with a 100-night trial policy. If you don’t like your mattress in the first 100 days, you are welcome to return or exchange it. A 10-year warranty is also available to purchase for $38.99.