Best Mattresses at Wayfair

Wayfair is an e-commerce company based in Boston, Massachusetts that has a wide variety of mattresses for sale. The variety is so wide that it can often feel daunting when you’re trying to choose. To help you make the best choice for your lifestyle, we’ve done the work and sorted through the site to provide you the best of the best of what Wayfair has to offer when it comes to mattresses.

Winners

Casper Element Mattress

Price: $695.00 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Firm

4.5

Why We Picked It

Featuring Casper’s proprietary Airscape foam, an eco-friendly material cover and memory foam that aims to support the body and increase airflow to help keep you cool, the Casper Element appears to be a good memory foam mattress for a reasonable price. Plus, it should come without one of the major drawbacks of having a memory foam mattress—overheating during the night.

Show more

Serta Perfect Sleeper Mattress

Price: $969.99 | Thickness: 12.5” | Firmness: Extra firm

4.3

Why We Picked It

Like the Casper Element, the Serta Perfect Sleeper mattress uses memory foam with a breathable construction that is placed above individually wrapped innerspring coils. This combination aims to provide a sleeper with the body-catching comfort of memory foam while supporting them through more traditional springs.

Show more

Signature Design By Ashley Chime Ultra Plush Hybrid Mattress

Price: $379.99 | Thickness: 12” | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Why We Picked It

The Ashley Chime Hybrid mattress seeks to combine a comforting top layer with a supportive layer of coils beneath. What differentiates the Ashley Chime Hybrid from its competitors is that—rather than memory foam—the top layer is simply high-density foam. There is memory foam in the mattress, it’s just placed deeper into the mattress itself in order to help support the back. The Ashley Chime Hybrid could well be an ideal mattress for back sleepers who are looking for a mattress with a soft feel that still manages to support the lower back.

Show more

Casper Sleep 11” Medium Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $1,295.00 | Thickness: 11’’ | Firmness: Medium

4.3

Why We Picked It

Featuring Casper’s proprietary breathable material and a targeted support system, the Casper Sleep 11” Medium Memory Foam appears to be a well-rounded mattress that offers a medium firmness, motion isolation, edge support and more. Most sleeping positions should be supported by this mattress as well.

Show more

Wayfair Sleep™ 8” Firm Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $179.99 | Thickness: 8’’ | Firmness: Firm

4.3

Why We Picked It

A gel-infused layer of memory foam advertised to conform to the body of the sleeper, this highly affordable mattress is also advertised as being designed to help a sleeping individual stay cool. Additionally, it comes with a built-in layer of protection against unpleasant odors.

Show more

Wayfair Sleep™ Arviso 10” Medium Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $375.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Medium firm

4.3

Why We Picked It

There are several layers of hypoallergenic memory foam used in this Wayfair Sleep mattress. It’s also breathable and comes with cooling technology. Additionally, the “low motion transfer” design used to build this mattress should help light sleepers stay asleep, even if there’s someone else who’s tossing and turning right next to them.

Show more

Wayfair Sleep™ King 10.5” Medium Hybrid Mattress

Price: $394.99 | Thickness: 10.5’’ | Firmness: Medium

4.3

Why We Picked It

The Wayfair Sleep King 10.5’’ Medium Hybrid mattress comes at an affordable price and includes hybrid features aimed at providing support, solid motion isolation and cooling. The combination of memory foam and pocketed coils in this mattress should also allow a sleeper to be able to sink into the mattress while feeling supported as well.

Show more

Wayfair Sleep™ 10” Plush Gel Memory Foam Mattress

Price: $329.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Why We Picked It

Featuring a gel foam with a quilted cover and a plush feel, the Wayfair Sleep 10’’ Plush Memory Foam mattress aims to provide comfort and support at a reasonable price. According to the Wayfair website, it’s designed with side and back sleepers in mind and should fit well into an apartment that’s short on space.

Show more

Wayfair Sleep™ 14” Plush Hybrid Mattress

Price: $469.99 | Thickness: 14’’ | Firmness: Plush

4.3

Why We Picked It

The 14’’ Plush Hybrid mattress combines coil support with gel memory foam, which can offer sleepers that “hugging” feeling from foam while providing pressure relief. A breathable construction should help a sleeper feel cooler during the night as well.

Show more

Novilla 10″ Medium Hybrid Mattress

Price: $489.99 | Thickness: 10’’ | Firmness: Medium firm

4.0

Why We Picked It

The key to the Novilla Hybrid mattress is the individually pocketed springs. These springs help the mattress feel both c breathable and steadier in terms of motion. Additionally, the Novilla 10” is built with moisture-wicking material and is compatible with an adjustable bed base.

Show more

Who Should Buy a Wayfair Mattress?

Wayfair mattresses may be ideal for those looking to buy a budget mattress that doesn’t feel like a budget mattress. They’re also a great pick for individuals who prefer to shop online, and who like the idea of their mattress being delivered right to their door—often in its own compact box.

What to Consider When Buying a Wayfair Mattress

Quality and Cost

We spend about one-third of our lives asleep or trying to sleep, which makes a quality mattress pretty important. Wayfair has several mattresses manufactured and tested for quality. 

Another important factor is budget. The prices listed in this guide range from $263.99 to a max of $1,295, which should fit a wide variety of living situations. Additionally, Wayfair has ‘Open Box’ options; their name for a clearance section of items that were returned by customers.

Warranty, Return and Shipping Options

Wayfair says that they ship large items through “trusted carriers that specialize in handling large items.” Every mattress purchased through Wayfair comes with a 100-night trial policy. If you don’t like your mattress in the first 100 days, you are welcome to return or exchange it. A 10-year warranty is also available to purchase for $38.99.